Justice?


It is a word spoken often. Justice for the injured, justice for the dead, justice for the poor, the disenfranchised, the mentally ill.

By “justice” do you mean “fair”?

By “justice” do you mean “equal”?

By “justice” do you mean “revenge”?

Is it “payback”?

After nearly 30 years in the criminal courtrooms of California, the answer is “all and none of the above”.

The California headlines today were about some  people standing in a courtroom accused of bribery and conspiracy for allegedly paying LOTS of money to get their children into specific universities and colleges. They were freed on one million dollar bonds. (More on this issue: https://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-loughlin-huffman-college-cheating-20190313-story.html)

That sounds like a lot of money but, to these particular people, they easily paid the price for temporary freedom. The cost was a mere fraction of their assets.

In 30 years of criminal defense work, the bail fight was almost always one of persuading a judge to set an amount the defendant could pay. It was almost always a losing argument. If the client had a job that they would lose by incarceration prior to any conviction, most judges were not impressed. If it would cause the defendant to lose a car or a house or any other asset to be incarcerated, most judges weren’t impressed.

To be clear, I am talking low level crimes–shoplifting, petty theft, trespassing and the like. The discussion on heavier crimes like assault with injury, first degree burglary, auto theft (not joy-riding) rarely occurred. There were few arguments to be made. Unless you were not represented by the Public Defender. Economic status meant something even for the higher level crimes.

Over the years, the price of freedom for the petty theft went up. The price for white collar crime went down. The ratio between the loss to the victim and the cost to the accused became skewed. There was no fairness, no equality, no proportion between the two. Income, class and race were the dividing causes.

The headlines also screamed that California would, for the term of Governor Newsome, not execute anyone on Death Row. I state my bias upfront. I know a man who lives there. I represented him. I believe him to be innocent.  For this discussion, I will leave an opinion piece from the New York Times.

There were times when I tried to discuss the disparities of race and gender with sitting judges. One or two acknowledged their biases None changed their ways. One was known for giving women defendants a “20% surcharge” because “woman aren’t suppose to act like this”. One gave nearly a 50% increase in sentences (for identical crimes) to Hispanics and Blacks. None were brought to task for their practices because of the way that the sentencing laws were written.

Justice?

It depends.

Categories: Criminal defense, Law, UncategorizedTags: , ,

5 comments

  1. I believe in the DP as do a majority of Californians who keep voting for it, but we are ignored on that particular topic as monsters like Scott Peterson sit on death row year after year. Which brings up the idea of why DO we vote on specific issues after we elect the Governor and all our Reps? They’re supposed to do their jobs and deal with these matters, not keep shoveling them off onto our ballots, each one accompanied by pages of legal gobble. Grrrr!

    But I hear ya on the celeb criminals. They’ll pay fines, issue tears and sorries, and have zero real penalties.

    Like

  2. Thank you for at least trying get to get justice. That must have been frustrating.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. It was also rewarding. Winning a case was an ego boost but having an old client look you up to say thank you was THE best.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. I don’t know how many people I can reach by tweeting this, but I do wish this would be widely read. It says something we all need to here–simply, believably, and in a way we can all (I hope) understand.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Tweet away!! Thank you so much!!!

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: